Unit #3.Lesson #4.Intervals of Increase and Decrease

So, I’ve had a number of people ask about whether the x-coordinate of a turning point should be included in an interval of increase or decrease or whether the intervals should always be exclusive.

Believe it or not, I’ve been tossing this question around for awhile with my good friend Brian Battistoni at Arlington High. This is a great question and it can be argued both ways. What we really need is for NYSED to just issue a clarification, so we can all be consistent. Maybe they will, maybe they won’t. I think it is a cool question because it can be argued both ways. Here’s how…

The Exclusive Case (x-coordinates of turning points not included):

This is the convention that most people will first think of because if the turning points were included, then they would have to be included in both intervals of increase and intervals of decrease, thus seemingly making the function both increasing and decreasing at the same point. This doesn’t sit well with people. On top of that, if you look at it from a calculus perspective and define the function as increasing when its slope is positive and decreasing when its slope is negative, then turning points, where the slope is either zero (smooth) or undefined (corners), should be excluded.

The Inclusive Case (x-coordinates of turning points are included):

To make and understand this argument, we need to agree on what the question actually is. Remember, the question is always phrased like “give the interval over which f(x) is increasing.” So, let’s examine the function:

quadratic shifted f(x)

Most calculus books will define an interval of increase as follows:

increasingdef

In other words, bigger x’s give bigger y’s. But, in the case of the quadratic above, wouldn’t the interval:

interval of increase

fit this definition? Remember, the question is not whether the function is increasing at x=4. It is whether x=4 is part of an interval where bigger x’s give bigger y’s. The x-coordinate of the turning point would certainly be included in this definition and is certainly included on the Advanced Placement Calculus exam. This inclusion really gets at a fundamental geometric idea regarding intervals of increase and decrease:

An interval of increase is a stretch of the function that can be considered going uphill and an interval of decrease is a stretch of the function going downhill. Aren’t the bottom and tops of hills part of these stretches?

What’s the correct definition? Well, that’s up to the bureaucrats to decide, which is weird to say. The one sample problem Albany gave us was the exclusive use. I’m amazingly inconsistent on this because of my own struggles with two equally valid interpretations.

Anyone want to weigh in?

Related Posts

We use cookies to offer you a better browsing experience, analyze site traffic, and personalize content. Read about how we use cookies and how you can control them in our Privacy Policy. If you continue to use this site, you consent to our use of cookies.
Terms and Conditions

Thank you for using eMATHinstruction materials. In order to continue to provide high quality mathematics resources to you and your students we respectfully request that you do not post this or any of our files on any website. Doing so is a violation of copyright. Using these materials implies you agree to our terms and conditions and single user license agreement.

Terms and Conditions

Thank you for using eMATHinstruction materials. In order to continue to provide high quality mathematics resources to you and your students we respectfully request that you do not post this or any of our files on any website. Doing so is a violation of copyright. Using these materials implies you agree to our terms and conditions and single user license agreement.

Members Only

The content you are trying to access requires a membership. If you already have a plan, please login. If you need to purchase a membership we offer yearly memberships for tutors and teachers and special bulk discounts for schools.

Login or Purchase Membership
Teachers Only

Sorry, the content you are trying to access requires verification that you are a mathematics teacher. Please click the link below to submit your verification request.

Complete Verification